Brooklyn Borough president urged resolving issues without cops; The advice got a constituent killed
A Brooklyn woman was killed after attempting to reason with several people illegally setting off fireworks in the neighborhood of East New York.
The victim, 33-year-old Shatavia Walls, was just following the advice of Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams to try resolving non-violent disputes through “community policing,” which does not involve calling actual police officers, Walls’ mother told the New York Post.
“She watched the news. Yes, she heard it,” Walls’ mother, Helen Testagros, said in referring to Adams’ advice. “It was probably in the back of her mind.”
“It’s not a good idea. You don’t know who you are approaching,” she added. “These kids are not respectful anymore — they’re more ruthless.”
For weeks leading up to July 4, New York City residents were plagued by people setting off illegal fireworks displays and, at times, turning firecrackers into weapons by firing them off at others. On the Fourth of July, Walls confronted a few people setting off one such illegal display, and told them to move their fireworks away from the children who were playing in the area.
During the confrontation, one person chased Walls into her mother’s apartment building, firing a single shot at Walls while she fled. The bullet missed Walls, and she was able to recover the spent shell casing and the driver’s license of the alleged gunman, which the person had dropped during the chase, Testagros said.
Walls reported the alleged gunman to New York police, though nothing was done, according to Testagros. The New York City Police Department disputed the claim, saying they did not hear about the incident involving Walls and a gunman until July 7, when the same suspect allegedly shot Walls eight times after she confronted another group of people setting off fireworks in the neighborhood. Walls later died at a nearby hospital.
Shatavia Walls’ family says she tried following Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams’ advice to resolve issues without involving police. She tried that with neighbors shooting off fireworks illegally. It got her killed. (Photo: Wayne Carrington/New York Post)
Borough President Adams, who is expected to run for New York City mayor in 2021, had urged people to solve non-violent disputes among themselves without involving police officers to avoid the risk of a police confrontation escalating.
“Stopping fireworks cannot turn into fireworks between the police and the community,” Adams said on June 21. “We want a good community response to dealing with a nuisance. This is a nonviolent act. So those three numbers that we all dial, 9-1-1, get over that.”
“We have left the place of 911 being the response for everything in our city. Now we have to stop talking the talk, and walk the walk,” Adams continued. “What does community policing look like? It’s the extension of everyday residents engaging with people when there are nonviolent acts taking place in the city.”
Adams did not back off his advice when addressing Walls’ death in a statement, instead calling for more action to be taken against “illegal guns.”
Adams expressed sympathy for Walls’ family, saying, “Gun violence has hurt too many innocent people in our city, from 1-year-old Davell Gardner to this dynamic young lady. Dangerous people are shooting innocent people for senseless reasons. I renew my call for cracking down on the scourge of illegal guns.”
“Our call is to continue building an ecosystem of public safety that includes community response and police. Whenever someone exhibits violence, we should call the police, but whenever we can communicate peacefully with our neighbors, we should do so,” Adams added.
The problem with Adams' confusing philosophy is that violence often is not present until a potentially violent person is confronted. By the time the violence begins, it is too late for police to be involved, if they haven't been contacted to resolve the issue in the first place.